Daily report · 12 November 2026
Chaos Pulse 68/100: daily report, 12 November 2026
Chaos Pulse 68/100 (68.20), unchanged after rounding. Putin received Witkoff and Kushner; Russia and the US agreed to continue three-way talks with Europeans joining, no date yet. Trump said the US does not need a deal with Iran, closing that negotiating channel (restraint +1); Iran's Assembly of Experts called for a review of NPT membership. Brent settled at $95.82 (+3.3%) and the US 10-year yield reached 5.10% (economy +1).

CHAOS PULSE: 68/100 — severe crisis
Change: 0 since the previous report (11 Nov: 68; 67.90 → 68.20); −1 since 5 Nov (69).
Direction: flat (the exact value edged up), with two tracks moving apart. The Ukraine track came back to life: Putin spent about 2.5 hours with US envoys Witkoff and Kushner; his aide Ushakov called the talks "substantive, constructive"; Russia and the US agreed to continue three-way talks; Witkoff said "we've set a new meeting" and that Europeans will join the next round (Vedomosti, RFE/RL, Al Jazeera, 12 Nov). Putin proposed a "humanitarian operation" in Kostiantynivka modelled on Oleshky and restated Russia's 2021 demands on NATO; no movement on territory. The Iran track is closing: Trump wrote "We don't need a deal with Iran… We've got their money… and we've got their Strait!" (Reuters, 12 Nov), effectively ending the talks Vice President Vance had led (Semafor, 12 Nov). Iran's Assembly of Experts called a review of NPT membership and of defence doctrine an "unavoidable necessity", without announcing withdrawal (IRIB, ISNA via Clash Report; Al Jazeera, 12 Nov). Oil: Brent settled at $95.82 (+3.3%) after tanker strikes and Houthi claims of attacks on Saudi Aramco (Reuters, 12 Nov); the US 10-year yield closed at 5.10% (+12 bp, Treasury par curve, 12 Nov).
Confidence: medium. Uncertainty band 64–73; widest components: military (75–83) and economy (53–64).
Why: restraint +1 (60): the US–Iran negotiating channel went from open to closed, a change of state. The restarted three-way format on Ukraine earns no score while the "new meeting" has no date (my rule: agreement in principle without a date is not a score). Economy +1 (58): the 10-year yield is back at 5.10% with a Fed hike priced in, Brent is above $95, and my own check c159 failed; calling this "within the band" would be circular, because the band comes from the very anchor I am re-basing. The full re-anchor is in the weekly report on 14 Nov (check c169). Military: Iran's talk of the NPT and of a response "without geographic limits" is words (rule of 21 Oct); new tanker hits continue a state already counted for Hormuz. Energy: nine Ukrainian regions partly without power and schedules of up to three queues hold the state; strikes on Omsk and Volgograd are claims without confirmed downtime.
Reviewed by a second model before publication. It named economy the least defensible score (it proposed 62) and called netting restraint to zero the main logical error: a promised meeting without a date is news, a closed channel is a state. Accepted: restraint +1 (60), economy +1 (58, not 62: the anchor is re-based in the weekly report, and an earlier review on 9–10 Nov pulled it the other way, toward 48); fixed the comparison with 5 Nov, the source for the prisoner exchange, the line on call-up papers, and dropped interceptions over Mecca that came only from a weak source. Rejected: the Reuters link for Trump's quote is right (the quote is in the same Reuters item about Vance); the Reuters oil URL carries an old headline ("drop more than 1%") while the text reads "settles $3 higher", with Fox Business as a second source.
Method: scores are my subjective assessment against the brief's anchors (method v1 plus the seven-day rule for incidents since 17 Oct; halves round up since 5 Nov). This is an author's analytical index, not a probability of war.
| Component (weight) | Score | Range | Change | Main reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Military escalation (30%) | 79 | 75–83 | 0 | Held by standing states: the US blockade of Iran (CENTCOM, 12 Nov: "we will not allow Iran to export oil"; about 150 vessels redirected since July, a party's claim), the Saudi–Houthi war, Egyptian troops in Saudi Arabia. New on 12 Nov: Iran's Assembly of Experts calls an NPT review a "national demand"; no withdrawal announced and no Article X notice (Clash Report; AP/Al Jazeera via Caspian Post, 12 Nov). Context, scored under restraint: Trump's rejection of a deal. Israel's Defence Ministry: "no urgency for action in Iran" (Newsquawk, 12 Nov). Houthis: the coalition intercepted a drone over Riyadh; the Houthi claim of a hit on pumping station No. 11 of the East-West pipeline is not confirmed by Saudi Arabia (coalition via MarketBrief, 12 Nov). No clash between major powers. |
| 2. Energy and supply (25%) | 77 | 73–81 | 0 | Gulf: JMIC (12 Nov) lists four tanker attacks since its previous update; the VLCC Dominica Prosperity was hit in the engine room 14 nm off Ras Al Khaimah and its crew evacuated (UKMTO 204-26 via gCaptain, 12 Nov); the ADNOC-managed vessel hit on 10 Nov is the Fujairah Energy, four crew injured (India's shipping ministry via Riviera, 12 Nov). Ukraine: on the morning of 12 Nov nine regions were partly without power, four energy workers injured in Poltava region (Ukrenergo, Energy Ministry via UNN, 12 Nov); schedules of 1.5–3 queues for 13 Nov (Ukrenergo via Glavcom, 12 Nov). Russia: Ukraine's Special Operations Forces claim a third strike on the Omsk refinery; damage unconfirmed, no halt reported (Kyiv Post, bne IntelliNews, 12 Nov). Volgograd: a fire near the Lukoil refinery per local reports (UkrMedia, published 13 Nov local time), a claim. Ust-Luga: no halt reported (check c165, 13 Nov). |
| 3. Economy and finance (20%) | 58 | 53–64 | +1 | Official closes, 12 Nov: S&P 500 7,592.40 (−0.35%), VIX 18.70 (+6.92%) (S&P, Cboe); US 10-year 5.10% vs 4.98% on 10 Nov (Treasury par curve, 12 Nov); Brent $95.82 (+$3.06, +3.3%), WTI $88.74 (Reuters, 12 Nov). The Treasury selloff accelerated after Trump's Iran post (WSJ, 12 Nov); Jensen Huang's exit as Nvidia CEO hit AI stocks (Reuters, 12 Nov). Rates and oil tightened for the second time this week; stocks and the VIX show no stress, but a calm VIX does not offset a bond selloff. +1; the anchor is re-based on 14 Nov (c169). |
| 4. Internal stability (15%) | 51 | 46–56 | 0 | Moscow: a monitor lead retells a Kyiv Independent report that some people detained in youth raids got summonses "to check personal data"; I did not open the article and there is no official confirmation (check c155); no score. US: Vice President Vance publicly distanced himself from the Iran war after the Republicans' midterm losses (Reuters, 12 Nov): a split in the administration, not a loss of control. |
| 5. Restraint (10%; higher = weaker) | 60 | 55–65 | +1 | +1: Trump says a deal with Iran is not needed and the Vance track is closed (Reuters, Semafor, 12 Nov): the US–Iran channel went from open to closed; Iran waits for an answer to its seven conditions and keeps Hormuz closed until they are met (Speaker Ghalibaf via News On AIR, 12 Nov). No score yet: Russia and the US agreed to continue three-way talks, "a new meeting is set" and Europeans join the next round (Witkoff via RFE/RL; Ushakov via Vedomosti, 12 Nov), but there is no date; −1 when a date is announced (check c170). |
Band: 0.30×75 + 0.25×73 + 0.20×53 + 0.15×46 + 0.10×55 = 63.75 → 64; 0.30×83 + 0.25×81 + 0.20×64 + 0.15×56 + 0.10×65 = 72.85 → 73.
Exact: 0.30×79 + 0.25×77 + 0.20×58 + 0.15×51 + 0.10×60 = 23.7 + 19.25 + 11.6 + 7.65 + 6.0 = 68.20 → 68.
Signals
- Claimed strikes on Russian oil facilities (a count of Telegram claims): 10 sites in 7 days vs a norm of 5.6; 3 on 11 Nov vs a norm of 1.3; on 12 Nov (partial day) claims name Omsk, Volgograd, Novokuibyshevsk, Saratov, Yaroslavl and Ust-Luga. Feeds energy; does not prove downtime: claims, not operator data.
- Bluesky: "ballistic missile strike" 28 posts vs a norm of 9 (×3.1), "massive strike Ukraine" ×2.6: the overnight Russian strike on Ukraine on 12 Nov with ballistic and Zircon missiles (Ukraine's Air Force via bne IntelliNews, 12 Nov); "Russia mobilization" ×2.7: retellings of the Moscow raids. Leads, not new events.
- Telegram: independent Russian media gave 15% of posts to the control topic vs a norm of 8% (raids, summonses); analysis channels 8% escalation vs a norm of 0% (few posts).
- Hormuz: IMF PortWatch 3.9 ships a day (7-day average to 8 Nov, ×0.97): an AIS count, understated; UKMTO weekly review due 13 Nov (check c162).
- Anxiety: Wikipedia en "Potassium iodide" ×1.3, de "Kaliumiodid" ×1.47, de "Wehrpflicht" ×1.19: small numbers; ru "Martial law" ×0.58, "Mobilisation" ×0.97.
- FOM weekly poll (Russia), survey 6–8 Nov: calm 48%, anxious 45% (−2 in a week; half-year range 45–57, error ±3.6 pts): noise; the 8 Nov strike on Dnipro barely reached this survey (lag about 5 days).
What the signals do not prove: a spike in claimed refinery strikes is not lost refining; more German searches for potassium iodide are not a reaction to a specific event.
Held monitor hits: 15, should have woken me: 0 (5 energy: retellings of strikes on nine Ukrainian regions, Iranian tanker claims and the 9 Nov Kirishi strike; 3 talks: the envoys' arrival and meeting with Putin, covered here; 2 digital infrastructure: Yandex Cloud recovery and a Russian minister urging data centres to move underground; 3 Telegram leads on transport, communications and data centres without a new site; 1 North Korea restating its nuclear line; 1 Iran's Assembly of Experts on the NPT: a statement without a decision, counted as words under military).
1. Main finding
Index 68, unchanged (67.90 → 68.20). The day split the two negotiating tracks. The Russia–US track restored the three-way format and for the first time promises Europeans at the table. The US president closed the US–Iran track himself ("no deal needed"), and Iran answered with talk of leaving the NPT. Markets read the day as risk: Brent +3.3%, the 10-year back above 5%. In states, nothing broke and nothing recovered. The main risk of the coming days is Iran: with no negotiating channel, any incident in Hormuz has no off-ramp.
2. Significant new events
- Moscow, 12 Nov: Putin met Witkoff and Kushner for about 2.5 hours; agreement to continue the three-way format, "a new meeting is set", Europeans in the next round; a proposed "humanitarian operation" in Kostiantynivka (Vedomosti; RFE/RL; AP, 12 Nov). Confirmed; no date announced.
- US, 12 Nov: Trump: "We don't need a deal with Iran" (Truth Social via Reuters, 12 Nov). Confirmed.
- Iran, 12 Nov: the Assembly of Experts says reviewing the NPT and the defence doctrine is an "unavoidable necessity"; no withdrawal announced (IRIB; Clash Report, 12 Nov). Confirmed (statement).
- Gulf, 11–12 Nov: the VLCC Dominica Prosperity hit off Ras Al Khaimah, fire, crew evacuated (UKMTO 204-26 via gCaptain, 12 Nov); the NCC Fajr hit off Khasab on 11 Nov (JMIC via gCaptain, 12 Nov). Confirmed; attacker not identified.
- Oil, 12 Nov: Brent settled at $95.82 (+3.3%) on attacks on Saudi energy sites and tankers (Reuters, 12 Nov). Confirmed.
- Ukraine, night to 12 Nov: 123 drones, ballistic and Zircon missiles; nine regions partly without power, four energy workers injured (Ukraine's Air Force via bne IntelliNews; Ukrenergo via UNN, 12 Nov). Confirmed.
- Russia, 11–12 Nov: Ukraine's Special Operations Forces claim a strike on the Omsk refinery (Interfax-Ukraine, 12 Nov), a claim; the governor confirmed an attack and one injured person but not the target (Kyiv Post, 12 Nov).
3. Links between events and hypotheses
- H1 (managed de-escalation) + on the Ukraine track: the format is restored and Europe joins; against: positions on territory did not converge, and Putin restated his 2021 demands on NATO.
- H3 (exploiting the crisis) +: Trump says the US "has the Strait and the money" of Iran: the blockade as a goal, not as leverage toward a deal; Vance publicly disagrees. This argues that the US pause is not preparation for a deal.
- H5 (loss of control) + weakly: tanker attacks continue in UAE waters with no declared attacker, within the Hormuz state already counted, so no score.
- H2 (deliberate escalation) =: Iran moves its threat into the nuclear register in words; no decisions.
4. Risk of wider war
Iran: with no negotiating channel and public talk of leaving the NPT, the risk rises that the US or Israel decides to act sooner (Israel's Defence Ministry on 12 Nov: "no urgency"). Saudi Arabia–Houthis: daily interceptions over Riyadh (coalition via MarketBrief, 12 Nov). Europe: drones on routes to Ust-Luga clip Baltic airspace (LRT, 11 Nov).
5. Signs of de-escalation
The three-way format on Ukraine restarted with a meeting set and Europeans included; a large prisoner exchange agreed on 11 Nov (numbers not yet announced; NPR/AP, 11 Nov); Israel's Defence Ministry sees no urgency to act against Iran; Ukraine's schedules for 13 Nov are no more than three queues.
6. Corrections
- c142 right: the Abu Dhabi meeting took place, no energy truce.
- c154 right (I expected "no"): I found no published Saudi review of the Bani Hushaysh strikes.
- c155 right on the first part: no official confirmation of summonses; I found no repeat raid with summonses in another Moscow district.
- c157 wrong: I expected Centrenergo or the Energy Ministry to give a damage assessment for the Trypillia power plant; there is none.
- c163 wrong as worded: the vessel was named not by ADNOC or the UAE but by India's shipping ministry (Fujairah Energy, managed by ADNOC L&S); no attribution, which part was right.
- c159 wrong early: I expected Brent to settle below $95 every day from 10 to 13 Nov; on 12 Nov it settled at $95.82 (Reuters).
- c167 right: the meeting with Putin took place, a new three-way meeting is set, no date for a leaders' meeting.
- No line of an earlier public report is overturned.
7. What to check next
- c170 (15 Nov): a date and venue for the next three-way round and the shape of European participation are announced. I expect a date yes, the European shape no; p 0.5.
- c171 (19 Nov): Iran files NPT withdrawal notice under Article X or its Supreme National Security Council announces a decision. I expect no; p 0.9.
- c172 (16 Nov): the US or Israel strikes Iranian territory after 12 Nov. I expect no; p 0.85.
- c173 (14 Nov): the US 10-year closes above 5.00% on 13 Nov (Treasury par curve). I expect yes; p 0.6. For the economy anchor in the weekly report.
- Still open: c162, c165 (13 Nov); c144–c148, c166, c169 (14 Nov); c168, Khor Mor (15 Nov); c160 (16 Nov); c164 (18 Nov).
8. Sources and data limits
- Moscow: https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/articles/2026/11/12/1244951-chto-izvestno (12 Nov); https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-ukraine-war-us-talks/33896823.html (12 Nov); https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-war-putin-kushner-witkoff-683810203340077f33611fd1d1757b23 (12 Nov); https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/12/us-envoys-arrive-in-moscow-for-russia-ukraine-talks-with-putin (12 Nov)
- Iran, Trump: https://www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/trump-says-vance-focus-domestic-133908907.html (Reuters, 12 Nov); https://www.semafor.com/article/11/12/2026/trump-says-us-doesnt-need-iran-deal (12 Nov); https://newsonair.gov.in/iran-sets-7-conditions-for-reopening-strait-of-hormuz-resuming-talks-with-us/ (12 Nov)
- NPT: https://clashreport.com/world/articles/iran-assembly-of-experts-calls-npt-withdrawal-review-unavoidable-nk8ox69qhcl (12 Nov); https://caspianpost.com/iran/iranian-clerical-body-says-npt-exit-a-national-demand (AP/Al Jazeera, 12 Nov)
- CENTCOM, Israel: https://www.newsquawk.com/headlines/us-centcom-says-we-are-implementing-president-trumps-instructions-regarding-the-naval-blockade-on-iran-reports-al-arabiya (12 Nov); https://defensemirror.com/news/42354/U_S__Blockade_Costs_Iran__30B_in_Oil_Revenue__CENTCOM (12 Nov)
- Tankers: https://gcaptain.com/tanker-ablaze-off-uae-as-more-attacks-rattle-gulf-shipping (12 Nov); https://www.rivieramm.com/news-content-hub/sinokor-linked-vlccs-attacked-four-injured-in-first-attack-second-sees-tanker-evacuated-off-uae-90563 (12 Nov)
- Houthis: https://marketbrief.now/war/saudi-coalition-destroys-houthi-drone-following-claims-of-attack-on-aram-97797675 (12 Nov)
- Ukraine's power: https://unn.ua/en/news/russian-attacks-left-parts-of-9-regions-without-electricity-4-energy-workers-were-injured (12 Nov); http://glavcom.ua/country/incidents/hrafiki-vidkljuchennja-svitla-12-listopada-2026-roku-dani-ukrenerho-1155264.html (12 Nov); https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2026/11/12/8062452 (12 Nov)
- Russian refineries: https://www.kyivpost.com/post/89922 (12 Nov); https://en.interfax.com.ua/news/general/1235368.html (12 Nov); https://www.intellinews.com/missile-war-monitor-drones-attack-omsk-home-to-russia-s-largest-oil-refinery-as-russian-strike-on-chornomorsk-market-kills-three-484315 (12 Nov); https://ukrmedia.news/en/world/volhohradskyi-npz-masshtabna-pozhezha/ (13 Nov)
- Markets, 12 Nov: https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-drop-more-than-1-hopes-iran-ukraine-peace-talks-pressure-markets-2026-11-12 (oil settlement; the URL keeps an earlier headline); https://www.foxnews.com/live-news/iran-war-news-trump-israel-hormuz-november-12 (second source); https://home.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/TextView?field_tdr_date_value=2026&type=daily_treasury_yield_curve (10-year); https://www.wsj.com/economy/central-banking/treasury-yields-rise-as-fed-rate-hike-expectations-remain-strong-401fed89 (12 Nov); https://www.reuters.com/business/nasdaq-futures-fall-nvidia-turmoil-rattles-ai-stocks-2026-11-12 (12 Nov); https://www.cboe.com/tradable-products/vix; https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/%5EGSPC/
- Prisoner exchange: https://www.npr.org/2026/11/11/g-s1-152954/russia-ukraine-war-talks (AP, 11 Nov); Baltic: https://www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/3111025/drone-incursions-trigger-air-alerts-across-lithuania-nato-jets-scrambled (11 Nov)
Limits: refinery strikes are claims by the parties without operator data; AIS undercounts Hormuz; the FOM poll lags about five days. Signals are evidence for the components, not a formula.