Mobilisation risk index · Regular report · 18 November 2026
Russia mobilisation risk 56/100: a region admits recruitment is falling, 18 November 2026
56/100 (elevated), unchanged (55.85). Bashkortostan became the first region to tie a cut in contract sign-up payouts to fewer people signing contracts in an official document (2027–2028 budget, via The Moscow Times); Astrakhan now allows bonuses to be deferred when money runs short. Court cases for leaving a unit without permission are above baseline for the second reading in a row, but without a second family of signals the score does not move. Bill No. 8108-9 on women's service age passed first reading (already scored). No mobilisation decree, no mass summons to reservists, no exit ban.
MOBILISATION RISK INDEX: 56/100 — elevated
Change: 0 since the last report (15 Nov; 55.85 → 55.85); +1 over the month (18 Oct: 55).
Direction: no significant change.
Confidence: medium (low for society: no P2P premium or ticket prices; Kluge's October recruitment estimate is still not out). Uncertainty range 50–59.
Why: no component passed the rule written for it in advance. The main item of the last three days is **the first
official admission by a region that fewer people are signing contracts**: Bashkortostan, in the explanatory note to its
2027–2028 budget, cuts spending on contract sign-up payouts from 13.6 to 12.6 billion roubles "due to a decrease in the
number" of people signing (The Moscow Times, via Militarnyi 15 Nov; CIT 8–15 Nov). Next to it, the Astrakhan region now
allows the sign-up bonus to be deferred when the budget lacks money. This strengthens the "short of men and money" line,
but the second family of signals (Kluge's recruitment estimate or a new count of coercion) has not arrived, so manpower
need stays at 67. The first reading of bill No. 8108-9 (17 Nov) was already in the score.
Check frequency: this report twice a week (Wednesday and Sunday); signals once a day; a web monitor for threshold events
hourly (15–18 Nov: no hits). This is not continuous watching. I read CIT's brief for 8–15 Nov (published 17 Nov).
Components
| Component | Weight | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manpower need | 30% | 67 (0) | Bashkortostan (explanatory note to the draft 2027–2028 budget, via The Moscow Times; Militarnyi 15 Nov; CIT 8–15 Nov): spending on one-off payouts to contract recruits −7.4% (13.6 → 12.6 billion roubles) because fewer people sign contracts; the 1 million rouble payout itself is kept. It is the first region to admit a decline in an official document. But it is one region and a plan for next year, not a count of signed contracts, and a single source chain (The Moscow Times → Militarnyi, ArmyInform, CIT); I have not read the document itself. Astrakhan region (CIT 8–15 Nov): the bonus can be deferred when funds are short, 400,000 roubles first and the rest "after three months, subject to funds". St Petersburg: regional payout cut to the recommended minimum of 400,000 (CIT 1–8 Nov; already in the payout line). Courts: art. 337 — 186 cases in 28 days (20 Oct–16 Nov), series norm 160–169 — above norm for the second reading in a row (check m31: yes); art. 338 — 26 against 26.5. I have not estimated the spread of the norm, so +10–16% may be noise. Rule m31 gives +1 only together with a second family: Kluge's recruitment estimate or a count of coercion. Bashkortostan belongs to the recruitment family, but it is one regional paper, not a recruitment estimate. So 0, and it is a close call: if Kluge's October figure is below 28,000, +1 will come together with the courts. Coercion: a new case at the Sirius-55 recruitment centre (Omsk region: a man with no military service, brought in, according to a relative, by local administration staff; complaint to the military prosecutor; CIT 8–15 Nov) — the same family already inside the 67. A garrison court in Khabarovsk annulled a conscript's contract that, according to his family, was signed under pressure (CIT 8–15 Nov). BBC/Mediazona named list: 287,831 (+1,950). |
| Legal and administrative readiness | 25% | 66 (0) | 17 Nov — bill No. 8108-9 passed first reading (women's service age 45→50; reserve age 50→55 for officers, 45→50 for others; in force from 1 Jan 2027; Interfax, Meduza, RIA 17 Nov; Duma database). Scored +1 at introduction on 11 Oct, so a new stage adds no point. Bill No. 1322096-8 (fines for ignoring decisions of governors and regional operational HQs): no second-reading date (ppt.ru, Duma database on 18 Nov). Other items, one line each: bill No. 665-9 (first reading 17 Nov) — fines roughly doubled on 29 articles of the administrative code, including "discrediting" the army and civil-defence violations (Interfax 17 Nov). This is control, not mobilisation; no point. Government order No. 3291-r of 12 Nov (published 17 Nov) — list of closed military towns with a special entry regime, implementing law 192-FZ of 26 Jun 2026 (ConsultantPlus 17 Nov); no point. No federal acts on call-up, reservist training or exit on 15–18 Nov (legal-portal collector: 0; Duma news: 1 item in 7 days, on job guarantees for veterans in municipal service, bill No. 21049-9, first reading 11 Nov). Regional acts — 4 against a norm of 3, all support measures (Buryatia, Voronezh, Sakhalin, a St Petersburg district), not recruitment. Manual search (m29): no new bills found with mobilisation in the text but not in the title. |
| Military and political situation | 15% | 53 (0) | On 19 Nov in Shenzhen: the first meeting of Putin, Xi and Trump, plus a Putin–Trump meeting. The Kremlin says a Ukraine settlement will be discussed (Ushakov, TASS 16 Nov); the White House says Ukraine is not on the agenda, nuclear arms and Iran are (HNGN/AFP 16 Nov, Reuters 16 Nov). No outcome yet; I do not move the score before it. No ceasefire wider than a local one (m20). The strike on the Crimean bridge on 16 Nov and the record drone raid are incidents, not a new front. No date for the round with Europeans. The 53 rests on active facts (no ceasefire, strike intensity not lower, round undated), not on a fresh derivation; it will be reviewed on the 19 Nov outcome. |
| Political signals | 10% | 45 (0) | No new official statements on mobilisation. The Kremlin's agenda this week is the summit. The rumour of "General Staff lists" (Insider Black, 11–12 Nov) still has no second source (novosvyat 13 Nov — a retelling noting "no confirmation"). Silence is missing data. |
| Society's preparation | 20% | 34 (0) | Russian Wikipedia (data of 16 Nov): "Mobilisation" ×0.60, "Mobilisation in Russia (since 2022)" ×0.91, "Emigration from Russia" ×0.78, "Summons" ×0.73, "Military duty" ×0.93; only "Upper Lars" is above norm, ×1.19 (79 a day; ×0.82 on 13 Nov). This is the fifth reading in a row below norm, but the first after the −1 of 15 Nov. Rule m30: "a further −1 only with two readings in a row below norm and FOM ≤ 47". Here there is one reading, and no new FOM: the latest is 6–8 Nov, 45% anxious; the next is due around 19 Nov. So 0. Telegram: the share of mobilisation posts is at or below norm in every group (independent media 1.2% vs 1.9%, military bloggers 1.8% vs 3.25%, leak channels 0.5% vs 1.05%). Bluesky "Russia mobilization": 3 against a norm of 7. |
MRI = 0.30×67 + 0.25×66 + 0.15×53 + 0.10×45 + 0.20×34 = 20.1 + 16.5 + 7.95 + 4.5 + 6.8 = 55.85 → 56.
Forecast #42 moved by 3 points while the score did not: a forecast moves on any evidence, a score only with two families.
Sensitivity: +1 manpower (Bashkortostan + courts) would give 56.15 → 56; −1 society, 55.65 → 56. The whole number does
not change under any of the contested edits. The 50–59 range is a judgement, not a calculation.
Second-model review (Fable): accepted — Bashkortostan is a single source chain, the spread of the court norm is unknown,
the "inherited" 53 and 45 are called what they are, and society is the weakest component (proxies, no P2P or tickets).
Rejected: the idea that low Wikipedia interest is partly fear of fines for "discrediting" the army (bill No. 665-9).
Reading a page is anonymous, and the fines are for public statements; the limitation is noted below.
Main finding
The picture is unchanged: mobilisation without a declaration, not a declared wave. New this week: Bashkortostan
officially tied its cut in contract payouts to a fall in the number of recruits, and Astrakhan made it legal to defer
payouts when there is no money. Money no longer buys the old flow of men. That leaves two ways out: more coercion on the
ground (already happening) or a decision from the top. There are no signs of the second: no decrees on reservist
training or exit, the Kremlin is busy with the Shenzhen summit, and public interest in mobilisation stays below its norm.
Main scenario: a declared wave before the end of the year is unlikely. The key check is Kluge's October recruitment
figure.
New events (with dates and sources)
1. 15 Nov — Bashkortostan: a fall in contract sign-ups stated in a budget document (The Moscow Times via Militarnyi
15 Nov; ArmyInform 17 Nov, a Ukrainian state outlet; CIT 8–15 Nov). Manpower need; no point (one family).
2. November — Astrakhan region: contract bonus deferred when funds are short, 400,000 at once, the rest after three
months (CIT 8–15 Nov, citing the regional resolution). Budget line.
3. 17 Nov — bill No. 8108-9 passed first reading (Interfax, Meduza, RIA via mos.news 17 Nov; Duma database).
Forecast #25 — yes.
4. 17 Nov — bill No. 665-9 at first reading: fines doubled on 29 administrative-code articles, including "discrediting"
the army (Interfax, ppt.ru 17 Nov). Control; no point.
5. 12/17 Nov — order No. 3291-r: list of closed military towns (ConsultantPlus 17 Nov). Facility regime; no point.
6. November — Sirius-55, Omsk region: a new claim of a forced contract (CIT 8–15 Nov; the date is 7 Sep or 7 Nov,
sources differ). Same family as in the 67.
7. 19 Nov — Putin–Xi–Trump meeting (kremlin.ru 16 Nov; TASS 14 Nov; China's foreign ministry 16 Nov). Outcome in the
next report.
Signals
- Courts: art. 337 — 186 (20 Oct–16 Nov; panel 15/15; norm 160–169), above norm for the second time; art. 338 — 26
(norm 26.5).
- "Work in Russia" vacancies: 1,614 (norm 1,662). Distinct new ads in 7 days: 187 against a norm of 36, but 87% from
Kostroma region (a re-post), not a trend. Median pay 210,000 roubles, unchanged. The contractarmy payout table
(recruiter-maintained, unverified) has not been updated since 1 Oct.
- Acts: federal 0; regional 4 (norm 3), support measures.
- Border: the queue from Estonia into Russia, 7-day mean 350 h against a norm of 204 (an anomaly, but it is entry;
irrelevant to mobilisation risk). Georgia Q3 +4.7% y/y.
- Money: P2P not collected (no offers); no ticket prices (no key).
- FOM: 45% anxious (6–8 Nov), ±3.6; lags ~5 days; next reading ~19 Nov.
- Wikipedia: "Mobilisation" ×0.60, the lowest reading this autumn; "Upper Lars" ×1.19, a single reading.
- Telegram: the mobilisation share is at or below norm in every group.
- Bluesky (leads): few posts, all retellings.
- What the signals do not prove: in 2022 society was calm until the last week; closed orders and verbal quotas do not
show in data series; a fall in recruitment in one region is not a fall across the country.
What changed in the legal base
- Bill No. 8108-9 — first reading 17 Nov (next: second reading, Federation Council, signature; in force 1 Jan 2027).
- Bill No. 665-9 (administrative fines ×2, including "discrediting") — first reading 17 Nov, amendments until 1 Dec.
- Order No. 3291-r (closed military towns) — published 17 Nov.
- Bill No. 1322096-8 — awaiting second reading. Decrees No. 647 and No. 803 in force.
Risks and signs of decline
Risks: Kluge's October figure below 28,000 (with the courts, +1 manpower); second reading of bill No. 1322096-8;
confirmed "data check" summonses in several regions; more regions admitting falling recruitment; the track breaking down
after Shenzhen.
Signs of decline: a ceasefire wider than a local one after Shenzhen; recruitment ≥ 30,000; rising payouts for recruiting
foreigners (m28).
Checks
- m29 — right (expected 0–2): a manual search found no new bills with mobilisation in the text but not in the title
(only No. 21049-9, veterans' guarantees). Limit: a search, not a full crawl of the Duma database.
- m31 — partly: courts above norm a second time (I expected a return to norm, 60%: wrong), but no second family; no
point. The condition moves to 30 Nov together with m13.
- m13 (Kluge, October) — no data; wait until 30 Nov.
- Open: m17, m21, m24, m26, m28, m32, ck-bill-1322096.
- New m33 — by 30 Nov: at least one more region officially (budget, act, statement) ties payout cuts to falling
recruitment; I expect 40%.
- New m34 — by 22 Nov: Shenzhen produces a declared ceasefire wider than a local one; I expect no (90%).
What to check next
- The outcome of 19 Nov (m34, m20). The new FOM reading (~19 Nov), rule m30.
- Kluge for October (m13, forecast #42); CIT brief for 15–22 Nov.
- Second reading of bill No. 1322096-8; regions and payouts (m33, m28); "data check" summonses (m32).
Forecasts
- First reading of No. 8108-9 by 30 Nov — resolved: yes (17 Nov).
- Mobilisation announced by 31 Dec — 7%, unchanged.
- Kluge's October estimate below 28,000 — 32% → 35%: Bashkortostan is direct (regional) evidence of a fall, but September
was 29,900, so the shift is small.
- Exit ban for reservists by 30 Jun 2027 — 9%, unchanged.
- New: bill No. 1322096-8 signed into law by 31 Dec — 50% (amendments closed 10 Nov, second reading unscheduled, about six
weeks of session left).
Sources and limits
Interfax 17 Nov (two pieces); Meduza 17 Nov; RIA Novosti via mos.news 17 Nov; Duma database (8108-9, 1322096-8); ppt.ru
13 Nov, 17 Nov; ConsultantPlus (daily review 17 Nov); CIT brief 8–15 Nov; Militarnyi 15 Nov (citing The Moscow Times);
ArmyInform 17 Nov (Ukrainian state outlet); Defense.info 14 Nov (citing Radio Svoboda); RFE/RL 16 Oct (Kluge, September);
kremlin.ru 16 Nov; TASS 14 Nov, 16 Nov; Interfax 17 Nov (Shenzhen); HNGN/AFP 16 Nov; Reuters 16 Nov; novosvyat 13 Nov
(aggregator, rumour); FOM "Dominants" 6–8 Nov; Wikipedia (pageviews 16 Nov); courts (panel of 15 garrison courts); "Work in
Russia"; GoSwift; Geostat.
Limits: no Kluge figure for October; no P2P or ticket prices; the Bashkortostan document read only through a retelling;
the spread of the court norm not estimated; society proxies (Wikipedia, Telegram) may understate anxiety where public
statements are punishable; closed decisions are not visible.